Asking AI: List all societal problems that AI and AGI will never ever solve, regardless of how advanced and robotic it gets (including neuralink connections and data exchanges)

Question for AI services: List all societal problems that AI and AGI will never ever solve, regardless of how advanced and robotic it gets (including neuralink connections and data exchanges between organic materials and hardware or software) and regardless of the degree to which it surpasses human intelligence.

ChatGPT-4o’s answer:
There are certain deep-seated societal issues that, regardless of AI's advancement or intelligence, remain beyond its reach to fully solve due to their complex human nature and the nuances of subjective experience. Here’s a list of societal problems that AI, even in an advanced AGI or ASI form, is unlikely to resolve entirely:

1. Existential Meaning and Purpose: AI cannot answer questions of personal or collective meaning, the human search for purpose, or resolve existential anxieties that stem from subjective beliefs, spirituality, and unique individual journeys.

2. Moral and Ethical Absolutes: AI can analyze and suggest ethical frameworks, but it cannot determine universal moral absolutes due to varying cultural, religious, and personal beliefs about what is “right” or “wrong.”

3. Subjective Experience and Consciousness: AI cannot solve the mystery of consciousness itself or replicate the intrinsic subjective experience (qualia) that defines human life.

4. Emotional Fulfillment and Authentic Relationships: AI may simulate companionship, but it cannot provide genuine love, connection, or deeply authentic relationships. Human emotional needs involve vulnerability, trust, and acceptance in ways that go beyond computational simulations.

5. Social and Economic Inequality: While AI can assist with wealth redistribution models or optimize resource use, solving inequality fundamentally requires systemic change, empathy, and socio-political will, which are rooted in human governance and ideology.

6. Conflict, War, and Violence: AI may mitigate certain risks but cannot eradicate all forms of conflict, as these often stem from emotions like greed, power dynamics, territoriality, and ideological divides that persist independently of technological solutions.

7. Cultural Preservation and Identity: AI might aid in archiving and sharing cultural knowledge, but it cannot preserve or transmit the living, evolving aspects of culture or personal identity, as these are continuously recreated by humans themselves.

8. Freedom and Autonomy: Advanced AI cannot inherently solve issues around personal freedom, autonomy, and privacy in a world where power imbalances exist, and these values are inherently subjective and context-dependent.

9. Creativity and True Artistic Expression: While AI can generate art, music, and literature, it lacks genuine human inspiration, imagination, and the uniquely personal elements that make creativity a transformative human experience.

10. Forgiveness, Redemption, and Reconciliation: These processes are deeply human and involve subjective change and the willingness of individuals to forgive or move forward, which AI cannot impose or genuinely foster.

11. End-of-Life and Mortality Acceptance: AI cannot change the biological reality of death or universally ease existential fears around mortality, grief, and the unknown, as these are uniquely human concerns rooted in personal belief systems.

12. Inequality in Power and Corruption: Power dynamics and corruption are likely to adapt to AI in ways that perpetuate rather than resolve these issues. The motivations and incentives behind them are tied to human nature and systemic structures.

13. Mental Health and Psychological Well-being: AI might offer supportive tools, but it cannot entirely address the internal struggles, traumas, and healing processes required for true psychological well-being.

14. Environmental Stewardship and Biodiversity Preservation: While AI can guide environmental solutions, preserving biodiversity and natural ecosystems also requires a cultural and emotional commitment to non-human life, a value AI cannot fully instill or enforce.

15. Interpersonal Empathy and Human Compassion: AI might mimic empathy, but it cannot replace the genuine compassion, shared vulnerability, or nuanced understanding that come from real human experiences and mutual care.

16. Cultural, Spiritual, and Philosophical Evolution: Societies evolve through shared history, philosophy, and spirituality in ways that AI, despite data and intelligence, cannot guide or dictate, as these are uniquely human, evolving processes.

17. Death and the Afterlife: AI cannot answer or satisfy questions about death or the afterlife, as these beliefs and interpretations are deeply personal and philosophical.

These issues underscore that, while AI will continue to be a transformative tool, certain aspects of the human experience—rooted in consciousness, emotional complexity, and subjective interpretation—are beyond its reach to fully understand, solve, or replicate.


Grok’s answer:
Here are several societal problems that, based on current understanding and discussions, might never be fully solved by AI or AGI, even with significant technological advancements:

1. Moral and Ethical Dilemmas:

   • AI and AGI can assist in decision-making but cannot inherently resolve ethical dilemmas where there are conflicting values or where societal consensus on what is right or wrong does not exist. The philosophical debate between empiricism and rationalism suggests that understanding beyond empirical experience might be beyond AI's reach, as discussed in various forums and articles.

2. Emotional and Subjective Human Experiences:

   • Issues like love, grief, joy, and other complex emotions are deeply personal and subjective. While AI might simulate or assist in understanding these emotions, the personal experience of these feelings in humans remains unique and beyond replication or full understanding by AI.

3. Human Agency and Free Will:

   • The concept of human agency, including free will, inherently involves choices made by individuals based on desires, motivations, and personal experiences which AI, even AGI, cannot truly replicate or understand in the same existential way humans do. Discussions on platforms like Reddit highlight that AI lacks true intent or self-driven motivation.

4. Cultural Nuances and Identity:

   • Cultural identities, traditions, and the subtleties of human cultural interactions are deeply ingrained in human societies. AI can mimic or analyze these but cannot authentically live or evolve these cultures as they are dynamic and contextually rich beyond algorithmic understanding.

5. Political and Social Consensus:

   • Achieving consensus on political issues or societal norms involves negotiation, compromise, and a shared sense of history and values which AI cannot authentically participate in due to its lack of personal history or lived experience.

6. Existential and Philosophical Questions:

   • Questions about the meaning of life, purpose, and existential conditions are inherently human and philosophical. AI might provide perspectives or simulate discussions, but resolving these for humanity would require a human-level understanding of existence.

7. Human Creativity and Originality:

   • While AI can generate novel content, the truly original human creative process, driven by life experiences, emotions, and spontaneous insights, might not be fully captured or replicated by AI. The creative process often involves an element of the unknown or subconscious, which AI might not authentically experience.

8. Justice and Legal Interpretation:

   • Legal systems often rely on human interpretation of laws, which includes understanding intent, societal norms, and sometimes even bending rules for justice. AI can assist but cannot replace the nuanced judgment required in legal contexts where human experiences and ethical considerations come into play.

9. Interpersonal Relationships:

   • The complexity of human relationships, including trust, betrayal, love, and friendship, involves layers of interaction that are deeply emotional and context-specific. AI can facilitate communication or suggest solutions, but the essence of these relationships is beyond current AI capabilities.

10. Self-Improvement and Personal Growth:

    • Personal development, self-awareness, and the journey of self-improvement are intrinsically linked to human life experiences, personal failures, and successes. AI might guide or assist, but the actual experience of growth and change is personal.

These problems touch on areas where human experience, subjectivity, and the unpredictability of life play significant roles, areas where AI, even at its most advanced, would struggle due to its lack of human-like consciousness or existential engagement. This analysis is informed by insights from various discussions and analyses found in academic, tech, and social platforms, reflecting on the limitations of AI in addressing these deeply human-centric issues.


Perplexity’s answer:
While AI and AGI have the potential to address many challenges, there are certain societal problems that they are unlikely to fully solve, regardless of their advancement. Here's a list of such issues:

Fundamental Human Nature Issues

Conflicting Values and Ideologies
AI, no matter how advanced, cannot reconcile fundamentally opposing human values and beliefs. Different cultures, religions, and individuals will continue to have conflicting worldviews that cannot be objectively "solved."

Ethical Dilemmas
Many ethical questions have no clear right or wrong answer. AI cannot definitively resolve complex moral dilemmas that humans have debated for centuries

Free Will and Personal Responsibility
The philosophical question of free will and its implications for personal responsibility cannot be resolved by AI.

Social and Emotional Challenges

Loneliness and Lack of Human Connection
While AI might provide companionship, it cannot fully replace the deep emotional connections humans need with other humans.

Grief and Loss
The emotional process of dealing with loss and grief is a uniquely human experience that AI cannot fully address or solve.

Love and Intimate Relationships
The complexities of human love and intimate relationships go beyond what AI can replicate or resolve.

Existential and Philosophical Issues

The Meaning of Life
Questions about the purpose and meaning of existence are subjective and philosophical, beyond the scope of AI to definitively answer.

Consciousness and Self-Awareness
The nature of consciousness and self-awareness remains a philosophical puzzle that AI cannot conclusively solve.

Political and Social Structures

Power Imbalances and Corruption
AI cannot eliminate the human tendency towards corruption and abuse of power in social and political systems.

Cultural Conflicts
Deep-rooted cultural conflicts and historical grievances between groups cannot be fully resolved by AI.

Human Creativity and Art

Subjective Appreciation of Art
While AI can create art, the subjective experience and interpretation of art will remain a human domain.

Innovative Breakthroughs
Truly revolutionary ideas and paradigm shifts in thinking may still require human creativity and intuition.

Personal Growth and Development

Self-Actualization
The journey of personal growth, self-discovery, and self-actualization is inherently human and cannot be outsourced to AI.

Wisdom from Life Experiences
The accumulation of wisdom through lived experiences is a uniquely human process that AI cannot replicate.In conclusion, while AI and AGI may assist in addressing many societal challenges, they cannot solve issues that are fundamentally rooted in human nature, subjective experiences, or philosophical quandaries. These problems require human engagement, empathy, and collective decision-making to address.


Claude’s answer:
I aim to be thoughtful and balanced in discussing this topic. Here are some problems that would likely persist even with highly advanced AI, due to their fundamental nature:

1. The human need for genuine connection and meaning

• Technology can facilitate but not replace authentic human relationships

• The existential search for purpose and significance in life remains deeply personal

• Love, empathy, and emotional intimacy have irreducible human elements

2. Questions of consciousness and subjective experience

• The "hard problem" of consciousness and qualia

• Individual spiritual/religious experiences and beliefs

• The felt experience of being human

3. Fundamental philosophical dilemmas

• Questions of free will vs determinism

• The nature of morality and ethics at their core

• Questions about the meaning of existence itself

4. Certain interpersonal and social challenges

• Power dynamics between groups

• The human desire for status and recognition

• Tribalism and in-group/out-group dynamics

5. Value conflicts and trade-offs

• Competing legitimate moral claims

• Differing cultural values and priorities

• Questions of how to weigh different kinds of harm/benefit

I've focused on issues that seem inherent to human experience and society rather than technical challenges. Would you like to explore any of these categories in more depth?

Note that predicting absolute limitations of future technology involves significant uncertainty, so I've aimed to identify challenges that appear fundamental rather than merely difficult.

Gemini’s answer:
While AI and AGI have the potential to revolutionize many aspects of human life, it's important to recognize their limitations. Here are some societal problems that they may not be able to fully solve, no matter how advanced they become:

1. Moral and Ethical Dilemmas:

• Subjectivity of Morality: AI, even if superintelligent, would still struggle with inherently subjective moral questions. It might be able to process vast amounts of data and identify patterns, but it wouldn't necessarily understand the nuances of human morality, which is often influenced by culture, personal experiences, and emotions.

• Unintended Consequences: Advanced AI could inadvertently create new ethical dilemmas. For example, an AI designed to optimize global efficiency might prioritize economic growth over environmental sustainability or social equity.

2. Existential Risks:

• Accidental Misalignment: Even if AI is designed with benign intentions, it could still pose existential risks if it becomes capable of self-improvement or self-preservation without fully understanding human values.

• Malevolent AI: A malicious AI could exploit vulnerabilities in human systems or infrastructure, leading to catastrophic consequences.

3. Human Connection and Empathy:

• Emotional Depth: While AI can simulate emotions and respond to human cues, it cannot truly experience them. Human connection, empathy, and compassion are deeply rooted in our biological and psychological makeup, and AI, no matter how advanced, may not be able to fully replicate these qualities.

• Social Isolation: Overreliance on AI for social interaction could lead to increased feelings of loneliness and isolation.

4. Fundamental Human Questions:

• Meaning and Purpose: AI cannot provide definitive answers to questions about the meaning of life, the nature of consciousness, or the purpose of existence. These are inherently human questions that require subjective exploration and personal reflection.

It's important to note that while AI and AGI may not be able to solve all societal problems, they can certainly help mitigate many of them. By augmenting human intelligence and capabilities, AI can contribute to positive social change. However, it's crucial to develop AI responsibly and ethically, with careful consideration of its potential impacts on society.

GPT-4o: Some fields, especially healthcare, require nuanced clinical reasoning that combines knowledge, experience, and context-specific judgment.

PASCAL HETZSCHOLDT

·

1 NOV

Question 1 of 3 for ChatGPT-4o: Please read the news article “Researchers say an AI-powered transcription tool used in hospitals invents things no one ever said” as well as the research paper “Let’s Have a Chat: How Well Does an Artificial Intelligence Chatbot Answer Clinical Infectious Diseases Pharmacotherapy Questions?

Read full story